Almost on a daily basis, we would hear complaints from the public that the services at the government hospitals are slow and they have to wait for a very long time to see the doctor.
Several years ago (I really can’t recall the exact year), a controversy erupted when a doctor was caught reading a newspaper when there were still many patients waiting to be seen outside. I didn’t blame him back then and I still don’t blame him for what he did. Sometimes patients make you sick… Really sick of seeing them.
Had anyone considered the fact that at least 70% (from my rough estimation) of those presenting to the emergency department actually have no medical emergencies at all? Many of them just wanted an MC so that they don’t have to go to work.
What about the public’s responsibility in taking care of their own health? If you have diabetes or hypertension or any other medical illness and already prescribed with some medications (the amount of which can sometimes be quite overwhelming), would you please take them regularly? If only Malaysians know how to comply to their medications, I think the burden on the emergency departments can be reduced by up to 30%!
Some of the ‘ridiculous’ cases that I’ve seen in ED:
1. A lady with a known case of uterine fibroid, already under O&G follow up and started on some medication to control her heavy menses. Her menses stopped 3 months ago. Came back to ED because she started having menses again (which is not heavy at all!!!).
2. A young chap with history of falling of the motorcycle THREE years ago… Came back to ED because his fingers felt somewhat numb when he woke up that morning.
3. A teacher with no medical illness who had spent the entire night marking her students’ works complained that she had been having neck pain when she woke up that morning.
4. An elderly lady with non-bleeding, reducible haemorrhoid, already under surgical follow up and scheduled to be seen in the SOPD that very morning at 8am just had to go to the ED at 5am that same morning because she was worried about her (still reducible) haemorrhoid.
5. A mother who brought her 1 year old daughter to ED because she claimed that her daughter was not taking orally well and had several episodes of vomiting (no vomiting was observed during her stay in the observation ward). She insisted that we give the daughter an intravenous fluid drip which to me was ridiculous as she was very well hydrated. When the IV line was dislodged, we asked if she could drink… We really wanted to discharge her. Mother insisted that we set another line (note that it was very difficult to get the line… The very experienced staff nurse had to poke her 3x to get the first line) for continuation of IV fluid. She insisted that her daughter couldn’t drink but I did see her drinking from the bottle TWICE earlier on (I’m sure she finished at least half the bottle). It took us another 2 attempts to get the second line. Oh, well… some parents are really quite strange.
6. One guy who appeared to be extremely well, came to fever centre at 5am. Annoyed, my opening statement (instead of the usual greetings) was, “Give me ONE good reason why you have to come at 5am… Just ONE… GOOD REASON.” He had already seen a private doctor 1 week before that and given some antibiotics as well as other medications. His fever and sore throat had already resolved many days before but he was still having some minor coughing, hence he had to come at 5am. I only saw him just before 6am. He then requested for MC. Feeling generous, I offered him a time slip from 5am until 7am, which was expectedly refused by him.
Don’t even get me started on those who defaulted their medications or follow up and came back with uncontrolled diabetes or hypertension… Or those who have already been advised for fluid restriction because they have heart failure but they think they are smarter than us and decided that they’ve been ‘cured’ of their heart problem, hence never followed our advise to control their fluid intake just to come back with swollen legs and difficulty in breathing?
Or those who actually have follow up dates in other hospitals but came to our hospital anyway because they thought we might have better service? Flattering thought… But useless. It would only cause more harm than good as some specialised treatment would be delayed. 99% of the time, we ended up referring them back to their previous hospitals because we don’t have the specialties specific to their illnesses.
Apart from ‘difficult’ patients, we also have to deal with stupid GPs. Examples of ridiculous referrals from private GP:
1. Persistent giddiness & symptomatic anaemia for investigation –> When asked further, the patient admitted to skipping meals in the morning and would have giddiness (not that frequent, anyway) in the afternoon and sometimes would get some palpitation and sweating. Resolved when she takes her lunch. Any clown can tell you it’s because of hypoglycaemia. I even knew that since I was still in secondary school. Anaemia-wise, she was as pink as any healthy person could get (in fact, I was paler than her), her haemoglobin level was 12 and I don’t think she had any symptoms of anaemia.
2. IM Cephalexin 500mg stat given (I didn’t know Cephalexin can be given intramuscularly!) but fever persists. Kindly do the needful.
–> Cephalexin is an antibiotic, you idiot GP (or is it a medical student doing locum?)! Of course it would not have any immediate effect. Note that the patient only started to have fever that morning and went to the GP in the afternoon.
3. To rule out dengue fever –> patient’s platelet level (done in the private clinic itself) was 240!!! Yes, we’ve seen one or two dengue cases with normal platelet level but when you see a normal platelet level, it is highly unlikely to be dengue fever especially if the level is >200. Perhaps it was another example of medical student doing locum in ED.
4. Kindly do a throat swab to rule out H1N1 –> we receive A LOT of referrals like this. We don’t rule out anymore. We just treat.
Manning the fever centre can really drive you crazy as people come with the slightest feeling of unwellness just to get MC or to request for a throat swab. I’ve come across several referrals from private GPs to do troat swab but the most ridiculous has to be this one: Patient’s friend is suspected to have H1N1. Kindly do a throat swab for this patient to rule out H1N1. The patient did not even have fever or cough or any other symptoms of any illness!!!
Many people came to our fever centre requesting for throat swabs because they are scared they might have H1N1. When we tell them we don’t do throat swabs, they get angry. They pay only RM1 and expects us to do a test which costs almost RM200 just because they are worried about that illness which most of the time is self limiting?
I myself am quite sure I would have been positive for H1N1 once if I were to do the stupid swab. It was a weird kind of flu… Symptoms that fit the stories of those who have been confirmed with the illness. I didn’t even take Tamiflu but I completely recovered 3 days later. I could have done the swab myself if I wanted to (we have unlimited supply of the equipment in my ward – the infectious disease ward) but why should I? It is a waste of money & resources. The swabbing part is extremely easy… But the cost? Has anyone ever thought of that? I’m not sure how much exactly the cost is for one throat swab but I know it is between RM150 to RM200.
As of 30/4/2010, we already have 54 (FIFTY FOUR! No kidding!) deaths in Malaysia due to dengue fever this year. H1N1 deaths? I don’t know the exact figure but in my hospital alone it is still zero as compared to several deaths due to dengue fever. Now, YOU tell me, which one is more scary… H1N1 or dengue fever?
Many parents actually bring their sons and daughters at 3am in the morning claiming that the children had been having fever since 12 midnight. They do have paracetamol at home but had done nothing to try to bring down the temperature. 3 hours of fever… What do you think we’d do? We’d just discharge with paracetamol anyway. I pity those sleepy kids who had been dragged out of their beds in the middle of the night by their inconsiderate parents just because the parents wanted MC so that they don’t have to go to work the next day.
If the above stories are not ridiculous enough for you, my dear readers… A policeman brought his wife who had recent history of gastric ulcer (it was just a Forrest III ulcer, no big deal), already under SOPD follow up and insisted for her admission because he had to go to work and there’s no one to look after her at home. He kept stressing that he was a policeman. SO WHAT??? Since when has the hospital turn into a nursery?
Sometimes, I wish I can say what my MOs love to say… LET THEM WAIT until they decide to abscond.
Some advice to the general public:
1. Do not go to the hospital requesting for throat swab. We will be very angry. Throat swab is a waste of taxpayer’s money and it does not change the management since it takes some time to get the result back. The principle now is just to treat. We don’t confirm the infection. Throat swabs are only done for patients who require admission to the ward.
2.If your children develop fever in the middle of the night, don’t panic. Given them some paracetamol (a.k.a Panadol). Bring them to the clinic/ hospital first thing in the morning. No need to drag them out from bed at 3am. In fact, if the children are not vomiting away or having severe diarrhoea or difficulty in breathing or bad sore throat or any other worrying symptoms, you can safely treat them at home with paracetamol. If fever persists until the 3rd day, bring them to the hospital. We’ll check the blood for dengue infection (the blood parameters would be normal in the first 2 days of infection).
3. If you think that your illness/ problem is not an emergency case, e.g. a paper cut (yes! There was a patient with paper cut on his finger, came to ED and asked if we needed to suture his (extremely superficial) wound) or having some muscle pain (we see this problem a lot in ED), please do not waste your time and ours in ED.
4. If your intention is mainly for MC, please don’t bother coming to the hospital. At most, we would only give you a time slip.
5. Please be patient and wait for your turn. You might be needing the service more than other clowns do but if they came before you (in the same category of urgency), we need to entertain them first.